Looking for the best Italian food in Atlantic City? You’re in luck – the city is home to a plethora of fantastic Italian restaurants that are sure to satisfy your cravings. To help you find the perfect spot for your next meal, I’ve put together a list of the 19 best Italian restaurants in Atlantic City.
So whether you’re a local or just visiting, get ready to indulge in some seriously delicious pasta, pizza, and more.
WILL YOU BE NEEDING ANYTHING FROM AMAZON FOR YOUR VISIT? Check out their “Deals of the Day”, and did you know about Amazon Outlet that lists hundreds of overstock items for up to a 50% discount? Maybe you’re in the market for some good walking shoes, a new camera, sunscreen or a nice hat to keep you from getting too much sun? You want to be comfortable and prepared, right? Amazon has some great travel essentials. Check it out!
19 Best Italian Restaurants in Atlantic City
1. Tony’s Baltimore Grill $
Tony’s Baltimore Grill is a classic Italian-American restaurant in Atlantic City serving locals and tourists alike since 1927. It’s the oldest pizza restaurant in Atlantic City! The restaurant’s vintage decor and cozy atmosphere transport diners back to a bygone era.
One of the standout items on Tony’s menu is their award-winning thin-crust pizza, which is available with a variety of toppings. They also offer many classic Italian-American dishes such as spaghetti and meatballs, chicken parmesan, and lasagna.
Tony’s always has free parking for their guests and the bar is open 24/7. Come in and enjoy the lively happy hour that runs from 4pm-6pm daily.
Tony’s is located at 2800 Atlantic Avenue, Atlantic City, NJ and can be reached at 609-345-5766.
2. Cafe 2825 $$
Cafe 2825 has been serving authentic Southern Italian cuisine since 1986. The restaurant’s name is a nod to its original location on Atlantic Avenue, 2825 in the Ducktown neighborhood of Atlantic City.
Their focus on seafood and homemade pasta will make your taste buds dance happily. Cafe 2825 also offers a tableside experience that involves the creation of freshly-made mozzarella. Check out the menu which certainly qualifies this as one of the 19 best Italian restaurants in Atlantic City!
Cafe 2825 is located at 2825 Atlantic Avenue, Atlantic City, NJ and can be reached at 609-344-6913 or by email at Cafe2825@comcast.net.
3. Sapore Woodfire Pizza & Restaurant $
Sapore’s menu is a pizza lover’s dream come true, with their wood-fired pies being the star of the show. Their sauce and dough are made fresh daily and they also offer a variety of sandwiches, cold and hot subs, strombolis, seafood, salads, appetizers, Spanish food and desserts.
If you’re in the mood for some seriously delicious pizza in a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, Sapore Woodfire Pizza & Restaurant is the spot for you.
Sapore is located in nearby Ventnor City at 6501 Ventnor Avenue and can be reached at 609-418-4430.
4. Angelo’s Fairmount Tavern $$
Angelo’s Fairmount Tavern customers rave about their lobster ravioli, a mouthwatering dish that is both indulgent and comforting. The perfectly cooked pasta pillows are stuffed with rich, buttery lobster meat and bathed in a velvety tomato cream sauce that will make you swoon. Check out the menus!
So, if you’re looking for a taste of history with a modern twist, Angelo’s Fairmount Tavern (since 1935) is the place to be. Make sure to save room for dessert – their classic tiramisu is a crowd-pleaser.
Angelo’s is located in the Ducktown neighborhood of Atlantic City at 2300 Fairmount Avenue and can be reached at 609-344-2439.
5. Carluccio’s Coal Fired Pizza $$
Carluccio’s Coal Fired Pizza in Northfield, NJ is a short trek from downtown AC (8.9 miles), but well worth that trek! Food Network’s Diners, Drive In’s and Dives has been here twice and their may be a third visit in the works!
Carluccio’s takes pride in using a coal-fired oven, giving their pizza an irresistible smoky flavor. Their menus feature a variety of toppings, from classic Margherita to inventive combos like prosciutto and fig. But don’t stop at just pizza – their meatballs are a must-try, too.
Carluccio’s is located at 1200 New Road, Northfield, NJ and can be reached at 609-641-4011.
6. Girasole Ristorante $$$
Girasole Ristorante is a family-run business passionate about serving delicious dishes made with the freshest ingredients. One of their standout dishes is the Carpaccio Branzino, a succulent Mediterranean sea bass. Another favorite is the Carpaccio Classico, a thin raw and chilled filet mignon with parmigiano reggiano, arugula and lemon. Yum!
All of their dishes are cooked to order, and not pre-made so that you can appreciate the quality and clean preparation. Check out the menu!
If you’re looking for a dining experience that’s both cozy and elegant, Girasole is the perfect place to indulge in some Italian comfort food.
Girasole is located on the corner of Montpelier and Pacific Avenues in Atlantic City and has ample parking as well as valet parking. For reservations TEXT 609-453-4015 or for takeout CALL 609-345-5505 (5pm-9pm). You can also reach them by email at dine@mygirasole.com.
7. Chef Vola’s $$$
Looking for an authentic Italian dining experience? Chef Vola’s is the place.
What’s most unique about Chef Vola’s is its location in a private home in a residential neighborhood. This iconic restaurant has been a staple in Atlantic City since 1921 and is known for its mouthwatering veal parm – a dish you won’t want to miss.
What sets Chef Vola’s apart is its unique atmosphere – it feels like you’re dining in someone’s home, with two floors of seating in a cozy, casual setting. Getting a reservation can be tricky, but once you do, you’ll be treated to an unforgettable meal and exceptional service.
Chef Vola’s is located at 111 South Albion Place, Atlantic City and can be reached at 609-345-2022. They are open Tuesday through Sunday.
NOTE: Reservations are a MUST and can only be submitted by phone. A valid credit card is required to hold the reservation and you MUST receive a confirmation. Reservation requests are not guaranteed.
8. Il Verdi $$$
Il Verdi, a sophisticated Italian restaurant, is a hidden gem in Atlantic City. Their menu features an impressive selection of classic Italian dishes such as Costata Di Manzo, a grilled 28 day aged bone-in ribeye, pastas such as Rigatoni Bolognese, a hand cut rigatoni with Il Verdi’s house made sausage ragu and hand dipped ricotta. They also feature delicious antipasti, salads and accompaniments.
Whether you’re stopping by for lunch or dinner, the expertly crafted cuisine and elegant ambiance make Il Verdi a must-visit dining destination.
Il Verdi is located in Tropicana Atlantic City at 2831 Boardwalk, Atlantic City, New Jersey and can be reached at 609-340-4070.
9. Il Mulino New York $$$
Indulge in the authentic taste of Italy at Il Mulino New York, where every dish is a work of art crafted with farm-fresh ingredients. The menu has many favorites and some surprises as well. Their Chicken Parmesan “Polo alla Parmigiana” is a must-try for any Italian food lover as are the anti-pasti, seafood, pasta, soup and salad dishes. Their Half Rack of Lamb is another favorite!
With roots in the stunning Abruzzo region, Il Mulino brings a touch of elegance to the Hard Rock Hotel & Casino in Atlantic City. The restaurant’s soaring ceilings and crisp white decor make for a luxurious dining experience.
Il Mulino is located in Hard Rock Hotel & Casino at 1000 Boardwalk, Atlantic City and can be reached at 609-449-6006.
10. Capriccio $$$
Capriccio has been a beloved Atlantic City institution for 45 years and is the proud winner of USA Today’s Best USA Casino Restaurant award for 4 of the past 5 years! Capriccio offers diners breathtaking views of the ocean and the city skyline with veranda seating available weather permitting.
Of course, the star of the show is the exciting and mouthwatering menu that features a blend of classic Italian dishes and contemporary cuisine. Only the freshest ingredients available are used. Don’t miss out on their famous Calamari Fritti, Insalata Capriccio, and Veal Romero.
Another perfect candidate for our 19 Best Italian Restaurants in Atlantic City list!
Capriccio is located in the historic Resorts Casino Hotel at 1133 Boardwalk, Atlantic City, and can be reached at 609-340-6300.
11. Pulia Ristorante $$
Indulge in a delicious meal while basking in the ocean breeze and looking at the breathtaking Atlantic view at Pulia Ristorante. This restaurant offers a taste of southeastern Italy without having to leave Ventnor City. The outdoor seating creates a perfect ambiance for an unforgettable dining experience.
Pulia’s dinner menu include family favorites such as Pot of Meatballs which are made of veal and beef with grated parmigiano-reggiano, Lasagna layered with ground beef, mozzarella, ricotta, pomodoro and bechamel sauces, and Braciola Gnocchi which is a sliced beef with homemade gnocchi and pecorino romano. You’ll also love their pizza, sides, salads, desserts, and yes they have a Kids menu!
Pulia Ristorante is located in nearby Ventor City, NJ at 5210 Atlantic Avenue and can be reached at 609-727-0395.
12. Carmine’s Italian Restaurant $$$
At Carmine’s Italian Restaurant – Tropicana Atlantic City Resort & Casino (caesars.com), you won’t need to fight over the last bite because their family-style portions are big enough for everyone.
The menu includes many favorites that will satisfy your taste buds such as Carmine’s Chicken Scaloppine, Veal Saltimbocca, or maybe you’re in the mood for seafood in which case their Broiled Lobster Oreganata is a favorite. You’re also sure to love their beef dishes that include Porterhouse Pizzaiola and Porterhouse Contadina! Don’t forget their delicious selection of vegetables, sides and yummy desserts as well!
Carmine’s is located in Tropicana Atlantic City at 2831 Boardwalk, Atlantic City, New Jersey 08401 and can be reached at 609-572-9300.
13. Martorano’s $$$
Martorano’s is not your average restaurant. It’s a full-blown sensory experience combining mouthwatering food, groovy music, and a cinema. Whether you’re a foodie or just looking for a fun night out, this is the place to be.
This Atlantic City favorite has a menu that will tantalize your taste buds. Try their famous Cheese Steak which will surely rival any others, or how about fresh mozzarella, made to order! Their pastas, aptly titled “Macaroni”, stun with options such as Rigatoni with Sunday Pork Gravy or Linguini & Clams. Then there are Martorano’s specialties like Prime NY Strip or Lobster Francaise.
Martorano’s is located in Harrah’s Resort at 777 Harrah’s Boulevard, Atlantic City, NJ and can be reached at 609-441-5576.
14. Angeline By Michael Symon $$
Michael Symon’s attention to detail and love for bold flavors make Angeline stand out. His passion for his Sicilian heritage shines through in every dish, from the homemade pastas to the wood-fired meats. You’ll be transported to his family’s kitchen as you savor red-sauce classics honed from generations of family recipes.
Angeline’s dinner menu is sure to make your mouth water. You could start out with the Formaggi e Salumi Tasting Board that includes fresh parmesan, fontina, ricotta, prosciutto, salami and soppressata. Then you can never go wrong with a fine Italian restaurant’s Antipasti or Pasta dishes. How does Baked clams or Lobster Fritti sound? Chef Symon does the soups, salads and classics perfectly also.
Angeline’s also offers a gluten-free menu as well as both Vegetarian and Vegan, for those so inclined.
Angeline is located in the Borgata Hotel-Casino & Spa at 1 Borgata Way, Atlantic City, NJ and can be reached at 609-317-8222.
15. Bocca Coal Fired Bistro $$
This contemporary joint offers everything from casual bar fare to upscale Italian dishes, all served up with a modern twist. But don’t let Bocca’s fancy menu fool you – their pork sandwich is a must-try, with tender meat and just the right amount of kick.
Bocca Coal Fired Bistro is located in nearby Margate City (downbeach from A.C.), at 7805 Ventnor Avenue and can be reached at 609-823-3663.
16. Jerry Longo’s Meatballs and Martinis $$$
When it comes to classic Italian joints, Jerry Longo’s Meatballs and Martinis is the real deal. Owner Jerry Longo is a South Philly native and brings his childhood Italian American culture to his food.
From Jerry Longo’s Philly roots you can transport yourself to the streets of Italy with their antipasto menu, featuring sliced-to-order meats and hand-pulled mozzarella that will make your taste buds feel like they’re on vacation. Or you might want to try “A Longo Classic” Meatball Salad or Shrimp Sinatra! Then there’s the “to die for” pizzas, entrees (how does Salmon Romano sound?) and sides. Whatever you choose, you’re sure to make your taste buds sing!
Jerry Longo’s is located on the 6th floor of Bally’s Casino Hotel at 1900 Pacific Avenue, Atlantic City, and can be reached at 609-340-1671.
17. La Padella Ristorante $$
La Padella Ristorante – About is where classic Italian cuisine meets modern flair. With fresh, homemade pastas and locally-sourced seafood, each bite is a trip to the heart of Italy.
Don’t miss out on their standout dish, the Brasato al Barolo, which has earned rave reviews. Their menu
La Padella is located downbeach in nearby Ventnor City at 7309 Ventnor Avenue and can be reached at 609-487-0600 or info@lapadellaristorante.com.
18. Linguini By The Sea (formerly Dolce Mare) $$
For a dining experience that’s as beautiful as it is delicious, look no further than Linguini By The Sea. Their classic Italian dishes have a contemporary twist and are served with breathtaking ocean views.
The menu is hard to beat! You could start with the Beef Carpaccio or Lobster Salad, then move on to Luganega Sausage or House-Made Meatballs, a couple Antipasti favorites! Still have room? How about Seared Halibut or maybe a 14 oz NY Strip to fill any empty space left in your belly? Be sure to leave room for a cold beer, cocktail or your favorite wine. The desserts are fabulous also!
Linguini By the Sea, formerly Dolce Mare is located in Ocean Casino Resort at 500 Boardwalk, Atlantic City, NJ and can be reached at 609-783-8000
19. Scannicchio’s at Lefty’s $$
Scannicchio’s has reopened and is now a joint venture with Lefty’s Pub & Grub. They honor the tradition of Scannicchio’s by offering the original menu as well as items from their Philadelphia location. Lefty’s management runs the bar and Scannicchio’s management runs the kitchen . . . a match made in heaven!
Here you’ll find the classics that you may remember from their 30 years of serving delicious Italian fare such as Ravioli Fritte, Escargot, many Antipasti dishes like Calamari Fritti and Clams Casino, a selection of soups, salads and sides. Then there’s the mouthwatering pasta and seafood dishes with meatballs, sausage, shrimp, lobster, clams or crabmeat. Finally, the menu wouldn’t be complete without steaks, chops, poultry, desserts and beverages. Everything you could want and more!
Scannicchio’s at Lefty’s can be found at 2647 Fairmount Avenue, Atlantic City, NJ and can be reached at 609- 348-6378.
Atlantic City is a foodie’s paradise, and when it comes to Italian cuisine, the city does not disappoint. From classic red-sauce favorites to modern twists on traditional dishes, there’s no shortage of delicious Italian fare to indulge in. Whether you’re looking for a cozy family-style restaurant or an upscale fine-dining experience, Atlantic City has it all.
So why not plan a trip and discover the best Italian restaurants Atlantic City has to offer? With so many options, you’re sure to find your new favorite spot in our list of the 19 Best Italian Restaurants in Atlantic City!
Make sure you don’t miss out on the ultimate breakfast indulgence in Atlantic City. Head to our latest post and discover the best breakfast buffets that offer a morning feast fit for royalty.
Maybe you’re in the mood for shopping after your breakfast or early dinner? If so, check out our post listing the 6 best shopping malls in the Atlantic City area!
